Green Bay Packers kicker Mason Crosby Andrew Weber-USA TODAY Sports

Mason Crosby or John Axford - Who is Worse?

During the dark days of the year when the Green Bay Packers and Mason Crosby are not playing, I turn my attention to that “other” sport, you know the one that the Milwaukee Brewers and John Axford play with that funny round ball and a stick.

Granted it is not football but it helps to ease my withdrawal. So after watching the Brewers struggle to a 2-6 start with the biggest reason being the complete and utter failure of Axford, I found myself asking, who is worse – Crosby or Axford?

Since the NFL season is only 16 games long, and the Brewers have only played six, I decided the only fair thing to do would be to take the current statistics of Axford and project them over 16 games and then try to make a comparison to Crosby.

So using my math skills and and all my fingers and toes, over a 16 game stretch based on the current projections, John Axford will have not converted one save and will drop his record to 0-3.  His ERA will skyrocket to 38.88 and he will give up 14 earned runs and just over six home runs during that stretch.

This all equates to one simple statistic, his winning percentage is zero percent and he will cost the Brewers at least eight projected losses. Now take Mason Crosby, the much-maligned kicker for the Green and Gold.  This season he converted 63.6 percent of his field goals and 100 percent of his point-after attempts.  From 20-29 yards out he was perfect.  From 30-39 yards away he missed two shots and from 40-49 yards out he missed three times.  From 50-59 yards is where it got ugly as he converted just two of nine attempts.  The only redeeming factor in all of this is that Crosby did not cost the Packers any victories.

So in comparing apples to oranges and going with my gut check, I would say that of the two players, John Axford wins the contest for who bites the most.  At least with Crosby you know he will make his point-afters and the majority of his close range kicks.  With Axford you know that no lead is safe, at least one home run will be given up and that beard or no beard, he will cost the Brewers the opportunity to win a game.

I do however, give a small round of applause to Brewers Coach Ron Roenicke for realizing just how awful Axford is and pulling him now.  I would have given him a higher grade if he had not put Axford in against the Cubs the other night with the game tied because in the end, Axford blew it and the Brewers lost.

Maybe, just maybe if Crosby starts shanking kicks again next season, Mike McCarthy will follow in Roenicke’s footsteps and yank Crosby before he costs us a game, but then again we have that Italian kid who could take over from Crosby and that could make Axford look like a pretty good choice to be our next kicker.

All I need to know is how much longer before the season starts because either way, my heart can’t take this kind of futility and torment.

Go Pack Go!!!

Next Packers Game Full schedule »
Sunday, Oct 2626 Oct7:30at New Orleans SaintsBuy Tickets

Tags: Green Bay Packers John Axford Mason Crosby Milwaukee Brewers

comments powered by Disqus