Skip to main content

8 Brian Gutekunst and Matt LaFleur mistakes that explain Packers' offensive line woes

ByFreddie Boston
2026 NFL Scouting Combine
2026 NFL Scouting Combine | Justin Casterline/GettyImages

Sigh. The Green Bay Packers' offensive line took one small step forward, then three massive steps back.

Brian Flores and the Minnesota Vikings exposed all of the problems once again in Week 10, sending the Packers crashing back to earth after winning five of their previous six games. Different personnel, different venue, same problems as Week 1. Probably worse.

Who deserves the blame? Brian Gutekunst? Matt LaFleur? Luke Butkus? The players?

Yes. The answer is, sadly, yes to all of the above. Under Gutekunst's watch, the Packers' offensive line has gone from a constant strength to a season-destroying weakness, and his biggest swings at replacing previous starters have failed the most.

LaFleur has made several questionable calls, most notably with his staff, and his game planning also raises eyebrows. He has set his players up to fail once too often.

Before we break down the defining decisions that led us to this point, let's first assess just how bad the offensive line is performing. The table below shows the PFF rankings for every Packers offensive lineman who has played at least 20 percent of the maximum snaps this season.

PFF rankings for Packers' offensive linemen in 2026
PFF rankings for Packers' offensive linemen in 2026 | Source: PFF | Graphic: Freddie Boston/FanSided

The 8 critical offensive line decisions that still haunt the Packers

1. Drafting Josh Myers over Creed Humphrey

Injuries to Sean Rhyan and Jacob Monk forced John Williams into action in recent weeks. That's unfortunate, of course. Most teams will struggle to survive with their third-string center.

But zoom out a little further, and the center responsibilities should never have gone to Rhyan in the first place. In 2021, Gutekunst had the opportunity to draft Creed Humphrey, now a four-time Pro Bowler with the Kansas City Chiefs and the best center in football.

The Packers needed a new starter after losing Corey Linsley in free agency, so Gutekunst turned to Josh Myers. The center-needy Chiefs probably couldn't believe their luck, as they selected Humphrey with the very next pick.

Of course, nobody knew then how it would pan out, but the pick didn't make much sense, even at the time. Humphrey was the more Packersy prospect, with the athleticism and college production Gutekunst tends to prioritize. The consensus board agreed, with Humphrey at No. 41 and Myers at No. 71.

Myers didn't stay beyond his rookie contract in Green Bay, and the team has since started Elgton Jenkins, Rhyan, and Williams at center. Gutekunst missed a golden opportunity in 2021.

2. Drafting no offensive linemen in 2023

Always restock the offensive line depth in the NFL Draft. It's the unwritten rule in Green Bay, Wisconsin, and one Gutekunst has typically followed. Not in 2023, though, even though the Packers picked 13 times.

He found room to reach for a backup quarterback in Sean Clifford, and burn another pick on a kicker in Anders Carlson, but not to add competition along the line.

It set them back years.

Gutekunst clearly liked the depth they already had, with David Bakhtiari and Zach Bako-Bewele at tackle, Elgton Jenkins and Jon Runyan Jr. at guard, and Myers at center.

But Bakhtiari had been in and out of the lineup since suffering a torn ACL in 2021. He'd play only one more game for the Packers after the 2023 NFL Draft. Bako-Bewele was unproven at right tackle. Runyan was entering a contract year, and the Packers were an injury away from starting Royce Newman.

The best time to draft offensive line depth is when you don't think you need it. Turns out, the Packers did need it, and it forced them to address the problem a year later.

3. Drafting Jordan Morgan

All of a sudden, fast-forward a year, and the offensive line was a need in Gutekunst's eyes. So much so that he selected Jordan Morgan earlier than expected, with many believing he was a second-round talent.

Gutekunst praised his versatility, believing Morgan could line up at four positions in the NFL despite only playing at left tackle in college. We've since learned that's not the case. Morgan struggled at both guard spots, and while his pass protection at left tackle is trending in the right direction, he's one of the league's worst run blockers at his position.

Many believed Morgan would need to play inside at the NFL level, and it initially seemed as though the Packers agreed. Most of his work in Years 1 and 2 came at guard, but that experiment failed.

If Gutekunst wanted to strengthen the interior offensive line, he could've considered Graham Barton, who went a pick later to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Many had called for the Packers to take Barton when the team hit the clock.

He is now thriving as the Buccaneers' starting center. His PFF grade ranks 19th at the position, and he's seventh in pass blocking.

Instead, the Packers are stuck with Morgan's up-and-down play at the most important position on the line.

4. Signing Aaron Banks, then doubling down

This will probably go down as Gutekunst's worst mistake for several reasons.

Mistake No. 1: Handing Aaron Banks a $77 million contract in free agency.

Banks was a capable starter with the San Francisco 49ers, but never looked like he'd become an elite player. The Packers paid him like a Pro Bowler. No guard in the 2025 free-agent market earned anything close to Banks' $19.25 million salary.

Mistake No. 2: Doubling down in 2026.

You didn't need to be an offensive line expert to understand how poorly Banks played in his first season with the Packers. Instead of absorbing the dead-money hit and removing the remainder of his contract from the books by releasing him, Gutekunst restructured Banks' deal.

It was short-term thinking, lowering his 2026 cap hit of $24.8 million, but making it far more challenging to move on from the veteran after this season. He was benched in Week 10, all but guaranteeing his time in Green Bay is coming to an end.

The Packers paid Banks $18.1 million in cash this year, which deepens their financial pain if (or when) they move on in 2027.

5. Hiring Luke Butkus

After promoting Adam Stenavich to offensive coordinator in 2022, Matt LaFleur hired Luke Butkus to become his new offensive line coach. Butkus had been Stenavich's assistant for three seasons, but his only experience as an offensive line coach was with Illinois.

The results say it all. Green Bay's offensive line has been in decline since Butkus took the job in 2022. That's not to pin all of the blame on him, but it's alarming. Here's a year-to-year breakdown of where the Packers' offense has ranked in PFF grades for pass blocking and run blocking since Butkus took the job.

Packers' PFF pass-block and run-block grades under Luke Butkus
Packers' PFF pass-block and run-block grades under Luke Butkus | Source: PFF | Graphic: Freddie Boston/FanSided

Aaron Jones and Josh Jacobs have masked some of the run-blocking woes. Butkus helped maintain the high level of pass-blocking in those first three seasons, but as the Packers have lost talent, the numbers have declined sharply.

Gutekunst deserves his share of the blame for that, but coaching is also responsible. It's one thing if a lineman isn't good enough to hold a block, but when you see so many communication errors and veterans looking confused about their assignments, yeah, that's on the coaches. The players look underprepared far too often.

Is it all on Butkus? Absolutely not. But the Packers' offensive line has regressed under his guidance.

6. Retaining Luke Butkus, not offering James Campen the job

Hiring Butkus is one thing, but even more frustrating is LaFleur's decision to stick with him. It's an all-too-familiar problem throughout LaFleur's tenure. He kept Joe Barry at least one year too long, which is probably being generous. He retained Rich Bisaccia despite the special teams struggles, and it took Bisaccia resigning to force LaFleur into a change.

It's easy to forget some of the offensive line woes from 2025. Pass protection wasn't nearly as dire as this year, but the run blocking wasn't much better – Jacobs' ability to add yards after contact masked many of the problems.

Back in January, many, including T.J. Lang, called for LaFleur to hire former Packers offensive line coach James Campen.

It made sense. Campen had spent time with the Packers' personnel department in recent years, so he presumably had a relationship with LaFleur. Instead, Mike McCarthy hired Campen for the role in Pittsburgh, where he's made an impact.

How the Packers' offensive line stacks up to the Steelers' in 2026
How the Packers' offensive line stacks up to the Steelers' in 2026 | Source: PFF | Graphic: Freddie Boston/FanSided

The Steelers' offensive line has played at a high level this season. It's hard to compare and put it all on the coaches, as they have different personnel and schemes. But it's not exactly a hot take to say Campen would get far more out of the Packers' players. He has a proven track record with tons of NFL experience.

7. Drafting Travis Glover over Christian Mahogany

Day 3 picks are dart throws, so it's hard to be too critical of Gutekunst for selecting Travis Glover in the sixth round of the 2024 NFL Draft. However, Boston College's Christian Mahogany felt like a no-brainer once he surprisingly fell to Round 6.

There was so much to like about Mahogany's potential, not to mention his connection to then-defensive coordinator Jeff Hafley, who was his head coach at Boston College. I wrote in May 2024 that the Packers may "regret" letting him fall to the Detroit Lions, and that's exactly what has happened.

Glover is unplayable at this point, while Mahogany has become a quality starter in Detroit.

This season, his PFF grade ranks 10th among all guards, including 13th in run blocking and eighth in pass blocking. He hasn't allowed a sack all year.

8. Drafting Anthony Belton

And it's a similar story with Anthony Belton. Is he a tackle? Is he a guard? Based on everything we've seen from the Packers' 2025 second-round pick, the answer is neither.

Green Bay selected Belton with the 54th pick a year ago. He started at right guard for much of his rookie season, but lost that job this past summer to Jacob Monk. Belton returned to right tackle following Zach Bako-Bewele's season-ending injury, and the results have been just as disappointing.

Belton ranks 148th among 195 offensive linemen in PFF's pass-block grade and 170th in run blocking.

Many believe his long-term future is at right guard. Well, I have bad news. The Packers would've been better off drafting another lineman who ended up in Detroit: Tate Ratledge.

The Georgia product went three picks later to the Lions, and he's found a home as their starting right guard. Ratledge is PFF's 19th-ranked guard this season, 33rd in run blocking and an outstanding fifth in pass blocking.

In an alternate reality, the Packers could've drafted Mahogany in the sixth round over Glover and Ratledge in the second round over Belton. Now, imagine in that same alternate reality, they never paid Aaron Banks. The outlook at guard would look very different.

Add us as a preferred source on Google